Posts

The Persistent Myth of the "2-Year" Rule in Disability Cases

Image
There is a persistent myth that after two years of incapacity or absence due to disability or illness, an employer is entitled to end the employment relationship on the basis of claiming frustration of contract . But does the myth hold any water? We will find out in this post. The Origins of the Myth What might be the source of the so-called “2-Year Rule”? WSIA One place to look is the Workplace Safety and Insurance Act (WSIA). Section 41 creates a statutory requirement on an employer to re-employ an injured worker who can perform the essential duties of their job until the earliest of two years from the date of injury – as one measure in the section. This would suggest that after two years , as one measure, the employer no longer has an obligation to re-employ an injured worker. This may be one source for the so-called 2 Year Rule . 2. LTD Policies Another possible source is the typical distinction between “ own occupation ” and “ any occupation ” commonly found...

Interplay between Long Term Disability, Wrongful Dismissal, Disability Discrimination

Image
The interests of employers and employees are always at odds when it comes to disability. Employers want to terminate employees who have been affected by illness or disability for frustration of contract . Employee wishes to keep his or her job by demonstrating a reasonable prospect of returning to work . In this post, we will examine the interplay between disability and Long Term Disability (LTD) claims, wrongful dismissal claims, Human Rights Code violations related to Disability Discrimination , and the Duty to Accommodate . Topics Will be Covered in This Post: Considerations in Filing a Long Term Disability Claim Wrongful Dismissal Cases Involving Employees with Sickness or Disability Defining Frustration of Contract Frustration of Contract Legal Analytical Framework Burden of Proof in a Disability Case Some Wrongful Dismissal Cases Involving Workers with Disability Human Rights and the Duty to Accommodate Employees with a Disability Legal Analytical Framework of...

Am I Barred From Claiming Constructive Dismissal or Wrongful Dismissal if I Quit Due to Stress?

Image
Section 31 of the Workplace Safety and Insurance Act (WSIA) provides a party to an action (usually the employer defendant) with the right to apply to the Workplace Safety and Insurance Appeals Tribunal (WSIAT) to determine whether the right of action has been statute barred by the WSIA . It creates tremendous amount of confusion as to what is statute barred and what's not. We will give you a high-level summary as to what's caught by the Section 31 and what's not. Table of Content: 1. Where Can I Sue for Job Related Stress and what's the Time Limit? 2. The Interplay Between WSIA and Work Related Mental Stress 3. Is Human Rights Claim Related to Job Related Stress Barred by WSIA? 4. Is A Wrongful Dismissal Claim involving Workplace Harassment Barred by WSIA? 5. Is A Constructive Dismissal Claim involving Work Related Stress Barred by WSIA? a. The Morningstar Decision b. The “ Inextricably Link ” Test c. Guiding Principle In a Dismissal Case 6. Conclusion ...

Termination For Cause After Waksdale v Swegon North America Inc.

Image
Waksdale is yet another watershed case decided by the Court, in which the termination for cause provision in the employment contract invalidated the entire termination provision because it violated the Employment Standards Act . Table of Content: Case History of Waksdale v Swegon North America Inc. Lesson Learned from Waksdale v Swegon North America Inc. Cases that have applied the Waksdale test Sewell v. Provincial Fruit Co Limited , 2020 ONSC 4406 Lamontagne v. J.L. Richards & Associates Limited , 2021 ONSC 2133 Ojo v. Crystal Claire Cosmetics Inc., 2021 ONSC 1428 Perretta v. Rand A Technology Corporation , 2021 ONSC 2111 1. Case History of Waksdale v Swegon North America Inc. The Case went all the way to the Supreme Court of Canada, below is a brief case history. Superior Court of Justice decision - 2019-10-03 - 2019 ONSC 5705 (CanLII) The Plaintiff has sued the Defendant for damages for wrongful dismissal . The Plaintiff moves for summary judgment under Rule...

COVID-19 Important Update: Infectious Disease Emergency Leave Extension!

Image
If you have been waiting patiently for the Infectious Disease Emergency Leave to end so the layoff clock could begin counting again, you'll have to wait a little longer, as there has been extension made in June. How Ontario Infectious Disease Emergency Leave Works? IDEL (INFECTIOUS DISEASE EMERGENCY LEAVE), O. Reg. 228/20 , was established during the COVID-19 pandemic. Non-unionized workers whose employers have temporarily reduced or cancelled their work hours owing to COVID-19 will be deemed on job-protected infectious disease emergency leave and will not be laid off or constructively fired at this time. Although most companies are not required to provide benefits to laid-off employees, an IDEL employee is not "considered" laid off and therefore is eligible for benefits. Click here to learn more about how the Infectious Disease Emergency Leave work. Ontario Infectious Disease Emergency Leave Extensions In September 2020, O. Reg. 492/20 , was passed to exten...

HTW Law - Employment Lawyer

Image
  HTW Law – Employment Lawyer Toronto Ontario. Servicing the Greater Toronto Areas. Wrongful Dismissal suing and Severance lawyer. Constructive Dismissal lawyer and Harassment lawer. Employment Lawyer experienced in Sexual Harassment and Human Rights Violations law. Professional Greater Toronto Area GTA Employment Law legal services. Free Initial Consultation with an Employment lawyer. Practical tips on employment law by an GTA employment law lawyer that cares about your employment law legal case.  No Win No Fee for qualified employment law cases. Sensitive employment law information is handled with care.  Quality employment law legal service delivers to you today. Offering employment law emotional support as well.  Call or Email Us Now for Immediate Assistance!!     Contact Details: HTW Law - Employment Lawyer Suite 1259, 251 Consumers Road, Toronto, ON M2J 4R3 Call Us: (647) 849-6582 Website: https://www.htwlaw.ca/ Gsite: https://sites.google.com/view/ht...